On Jan. 28, Avery Murray, a 15-year-old Champlain Valley Union High School student, saw something she may never forget – her 12-year-old sister Rieanna almost hit by a pickup truck.

The truck was illegally passing their school bus.

The bus was stopped, red lights flashing and stop sign out, waiting for the girls to cross Highway 116, a couple of miles south of Hinesburg Community School.

Video footage from the bus’s camera shows the terrifying second when the middle schooler steps from the curb and into the road, a rushing truck whooshing past.

What the video doesn’t have is the sound of Avery’s scream, just before Rieanna would have been hit, possibly killed or seriously hurt.

“It was a tone that my 12-year-old said she was not used to hearing and that caused her to hesitate and pull back,” said the girls’ mother, Tammy Murray. “She doesn’t know what made her step back. … She just felt this whoosh go by her face.”

The girls were so startled that they couldn’t give specific details about the truck.

They think it was a dark pickup.

But they’re not sure.

Tammy Murray said her daughters were in such a state of shock that it’s hard for them to remember.

It is unclear from the bus camera video, too.

The video shows the girls’ feet. One of the pairs of feet are just stepping into the road and then suddenly stepping backward into the snow.

In the dark morning light, the video shows a small portion of what appears to be a dark pickup truck moving past.

One thing is starkly clear – it misses Rieanna by inches.

No exceptions

Drivers shouldn’t pass a school bus going either direction, if the bus has its lights on and stop sign out, any time, said Champlain Valley School District Bus Driver Supervisor Ken Martin. “God forbid they run through the red lights and hit a child. Their life is ruined forever.”

Passing a school bus is so serious that even the police can’t do it when its warning lights are flashing and stop sign is out – whether they are approaching the bus from behind or passing in the other lane going in the opposite direction.

Again, no exceptions!

One more time for emphasis: When a school bus is stopped and its warning signals are flashing, all traffic is must stop, going both ways.

It’s the only piece of motor vehicle law enforcement with no exceptions for law enforcement, said Hinesburg Police Officer Britt Lindemuth.

“I can go down a one-way street at 60 miles per hour, if I exercise due discretion,” Lindemuth said. “But I can’t go around a bus if the bus has its red lights on.”

“Authorized emergency vehicles shall come to a full stop when approaching a school bus which is flashing red lights and may proceed only when the flashing red lights are extinguished,” says 23 V.S.A. § 1015 of the Vermont statutes pertaining to exemptions for emergency vehicles. All the rest of this section deals with exemptions, except for school buses.

There are none.

Shelburne Police Chief Aaron Noble said people illegally passing school buses has been a problem forever. Recently his department has assigned an officer to Shelburne Community School in the mornings and afternoons, in part to work on school bus safety.

Since he took the duty, Officer Kyle Brooks has followed school buses most mornings. In two weeks, he’s had an incident where two vehicles passed a school bus with its stop sign out and red lights blinking on Shelburne Road, just north of Harbor Road.

He managed to stop both vehicles, and both drivers told him they didn’t see the school bus.

“It’s a stop sign. It’s hanging out. It’s a big yellow bus with red lights,” he said. “It seems pretty straightforward to me.”

Brooks said it had to be distracted driving, but he didn’t know what the distraction was. “I didn’t see a cell phone in their hands. … It’s just one of those mysteries.”

New cameras reveal problem

Hinesburg Police Chief Anthony Cambridge recalled Martin saying at Champlain Valley Union High School’s Safety Committee that, with the new cameras installed on the buses, he was surprised to see how many vehicles were passing stopped school buses.

“So, we knew we had a problem,” said Cambridge.

This impression was confirmed last week when Lindemuth was summoned to Hinesburg Community School because of a confrontation between a motorist and a bus driver. The motorist was upset, the incident report says, “because the bus driver was too aggressive with him” when he confronted him about passing the bus in the school’s bus lane while its lights were flashing and stop sign was out.

The driver incorrectly believed that the laws about not passing school buses didn’t apply on school property.

It sounds like bus drivers are really tired of this situation, said Lindemuth. “The perception of the bus drivers is it’s out of control. All of them are passed by cars. It’s multiple times a day sometimes.”

He said that Hinesburg police have conducted three “directed patrols,” a sort of a rolling stakeout focused on enforcing school bus no-passing laws.

“People should know that on a near daily basis that’s going to keep on happening,” said Lindemuth. “As a former school resource officer who cares about the safety of kids, it is something I’m personally going to enforce. We’re going to get back to the standard in Hinesburg. Nobody should doubt that we’re going to stick to this.”

And the repercussions for someone who is caught will be painful. The hurt will be much more than $249 ticket. – five points can be added to a license, said Lindemuth, which is halfway to suspension.

He said, “By the time you’re done with insurance, that’s going to be a much bigger expense than $249.”

Reliable news and information is vitally important. Local advertising has been affected by the COVID-19 crisis but the Vermont Community Newspaper Group remains committed to its responsibility to serve its communities. Your communities. With some assistance from loyal readers, community organizations, foundations and other funders, we hope to keep reporters on the job keeping you informed. Please consider making a tax-deductible donation to our local journalism fund. Thank you for your support.

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexual language.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be proactive. Use the "Report" link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.